Italian Restaurants in Coney Island - Sheepshead Bay

• L & B Pizzeria ($)
  

  4.3 57 reviews

  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
  2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 449-1230 (718) 449-1230
• Michael's Restaurant ($$$)
  

  4.3 33 reviews

  Italian
  2929 Avenue R, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 998-7851 (718) 998-7851
• Gargiulo's Restaurant ($$$)
  

  4.0 42 reviews

  Italian
  2911 W 15th St, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 266-4891 (718) 266-4891
• Anthony's Place ($$)
  

  4.2 23 reviews

  Italian
  2110 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 743-8099 (718) 743-8099
• Joe's Of Avenue U Sicilian ($$)
  

  4.4 42 reviews

  Italian, Vegetarian
  287 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 449-9285 (718) 449-9285
• Knapp Pizza II ($)
  

  4.4 22 reviews

  Italian, Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches
  261 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 376-0174 (718) 376-0174
• Next Door ($$)
  

  4.6 22 reviews

  Italian
  2005 Emmons Ave, Sheepshead Bay, NY
  (718) 942-5870 (718) 942-5870
• Italia Pizzia & Restaurant ($)
  

  4.3 10 reviews

  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Italian
  307 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 339-0666 (718) 339-0666
• Trio Pizzeria ($)
  

  3.5 23 reviews

  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Bar, Italian
  1907 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 934-8137 (718) 934-8137
• G S Salumeria Pork Store ($$)
  

  4.4 31 reviews

  Italian, Sandwiches, Subs, Meat Shops
  2611 Ave U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 646-9111 (718) 646-9111
• Enzo's Pizzeria & Italian Spec ($)
  

  3.5 6 reviews

  Pizza, Subs, Sandwiches, Italian
  482 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 376-0875 (718) 376-0875
• La Tombola Restaurant ($$)
  

  3.6 7 reviews

  Italian, American, Bar
  2102 Riegelmann Boardwalk, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 702-3092 (718) 702-3092
• Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay ($$)
  

  3.9 27 reviews

  Italian
  1901 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 942-4848 (718) 942-4848
• Siena Ristorante ($$$)
  

  4.2 25 reviews

  Kosher, Italian
  533 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 676-5024 (718) 676-5024
• Five Brother's Pizza, Pasta and Grill ($$)
  

  3.0 4 reviews

  Italian, Pizza
  2650 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 648-1600 (718) 648-1600
• Daddy's Pizza and Pasta ($$)
  

  4.5 13 reviews

  Pasta, Italian, Pizza
  2625 86th St, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 676-2698 (718) 676-2698
• Kosher Bravo Pizza ($)
  

  4.2 13 reviews

  Pizza, Italian
  902 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY
  (347) 702-5121 (347) 702-5121
• Cafe on the Hill ($$)
  

  4.6 13 reviews

  Sandwiches, Subs, Italian, Cafe
  153 Ave U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 266-0107 (718) 266-0107
• Clemente's ($$)
  

  4.6 19 reviews

  Sandwiches, Subs, Breakfast, Brunch, Italian
  138 Ave T, Brooklyn, NY
  (800) 427-0556 (800) 427-0556
• Teura Albanian & Italian Restaurant ($)
  

  5.0 2 reviews

  Italian, Mediterranean, Seafood
  1215 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (347) 312-7772 (347) 312-7772
• Lucia Pizza ($)
  

  4.4 8 reviews

  Pizza, Italian
  2201 Avenue X, New York, NY
  (718) 313-0999 (718) 313-0999
• Castell's Restaurant ($)
  

  5.0 1 review

  Italian
  222 Ave U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 908-0060 (718) 908-0060
• Nota Bene Restaurant ($)
  

  5.0 5 reviews

  Italian
  282 Brighton Beach Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 676-0297 (718) 676-0297
• Enzo's Pizza ($)
  

  3.9 19 reviews

  Italian, Pizza
  1623 Oriental Blvd, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 743-9056 (718) 743-9056
• Sammy's Italian Eatery ($)
  

  5.0 2 reviews

  Italian, Pizza
  3003 Ave U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 676-1654 (718) 676-1654
• Papa Razzi ($)
  

  0.0 0 review

  Italian
  464 Ave U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 382-6262 (718) 382-6262
• Bon Appetit Restaurant ($$)
  

  0.0 0 review

  Italian, French, Seafood
  2960 Ave S, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 382-4500 (718) 382-4500
• Coney Island Surf and Turf Grill ($) - Closed
  

  4.0 3 reviews

  Seafood, American, Italian
  1315 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 513-6491 (718) 513-6491
• Fiorentino's Ristorante ($$) - Closed
  

  3.5 6 reviews

  Italian
  311 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 372-1445 (718) 372-1445
• II Fornetto ($$) - Closed
  

  4.0 15 reviews

  Italian, Seafood
  2902 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 332-8494 (718) 332-8494
• Luigis Restaurant ($) - Closed
  

  4.5 4 reviews

  Italian
  316 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 232-6691 (718) 232-6691
• Maria's Restaurant ($$) - Closed
  

  4.0 5 reviews

  Italian, Seafood
  3073 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 646-6665 (718) 646-6665
• Giovanni's ($$) - Closed
  

  4.7 9 reviews

  Italian
  192 Ave U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 372-1440 (718) 372-1440
• Walburgers ($$) - Closed
  

  2.7 3 reviews

  Italian, Burgers, American
  3015 Stillwell Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 942-4450 (718) 942-4450
• Tre Fontane ($$) - Closed
  

  3.6 10 reviews

  Italian, Pizza, Lounges, Salads, Pasta
  222 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 872-7180 (718) 872-7180
• My Pizza ($) - Closed
  

  1.8 6 reviews

  Italian
  3033 Avenue V, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 513-0888 (718) 513-0888
• La Strega ($$) - Closed
  

  4.0 2 reviews

  Mediterranean, Italian, Lounges, Bar
  2085 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 215-9005 (718) 215-9005
• Classic Heros ($) - Closed
  

  0.0 0 review

  Sandwiches, Subs, American, Italian
  1410 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 266-4376 (718) 266-4376
• CHIPP Neapolitan Pizza ($) - Closed
  

  0.0 0 review

  International, Italian, Pizza
  2971 Ocean Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 934-4100 (718) 934-4100
• Concetta Restaurant ($$) - Closed
  

  1.5 2 reviews

  Italian
  248 Avenue X, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 645-5158 (718) 645-5158
• Giovannis Brick Oven ($) - Closed
  

  3.5 4 reviews

  Italian, Pizza
  1323 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 645-6010 (718) 645-6010
• Gusto Italiano ($$) - Closed
  

  0.0 0 review

  Italian
  153 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 946-3753 (718) 946-3753
• La Trattoria Italiana ($$) - Closed
  

  0.0 0 review

  Italian
  2811 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 648-0334 (718) 648-0334
• Tre Fratelli ($$) - Closed
  

  0.0 0 review

  Italian, Californian
  2311 Avenue Z, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 891-3816 (718) 891-3816
• Vinnies II Italian Restaurant ($$$) - Closed
  

  0.0 0 review

  Italian
  263 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 265-9019 (718) 265-9019
• Vitale's Italian Restaurant ($$$) - Closed
  

  5.0 2 reviews

  Italian
  1949 Mcdonald Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 998-3597 (718) 998-3597
• Elena's Diner ($$) - Closed
  

  5.0 1 review

  Diner, Italian
  311 Ave X, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 645-9005 (718) 645-9005
• Vittoria Seafood and Grill ($$) - Closed
  

  5.0 1 review

  Italian, American
  3081 Emmons Ave, New York, NY
  (718) 646-3800 (718) 646-3800
• Bari Pork Store ($$) - Closed
  

  4.7 3 reviews

  Italian, Sandwiches, Subs, Meat Shops
  158 Ave U, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 372-6405 (718) 372-6405
• Aqua Blu Supper Club ($$$) - Closed
  

  3.3 12 reviews

  Italian
  152 Highlawn Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  (718) 872-5000 (718) 872-5000