DiTondo's Tavern

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

370 Seneca St
Buffalo, NY 14204

Phone: (716) 855-8838

Website

Neighborhood: Buffalo

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for DiTondo's Tavern

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for DiTondo's Tavern

Write a Review

  3.8 stars - Based on 39 reviews

#250 out of 1392 restaurants in Buffalo

#17 of 39 Italian in Buffalo

5 star				10 reviews	26%
4 star				19 reviews	49%
3 star				6 reviews	15%
2 star				1 review	3%
1 star				3 reviews	8%

Top Reviews of DiTondo's Tavern

04/19/2025 - Yoshi R.
The long-awaited outing exceeded my expectations, showcasing an elegant yet understated decor that perfectly complemented the exquisite Italian cuisine. Highlights included the delicate purple potato gnocchi and an impressive selection of seafood, with the lasagna standing out for its rich flavors. While the meal was exceptional, a few service aspects, such as the wine pricing and room temperature cappuccino, left room for improvement, but the overall dining experience was memorable.

03/13/2025 - Deborah L.
This long-awaited outing exceeded my expectations with its upscale decor and an impressive array of authentic Italian dishes. The flavors were incredible, from the delicate purple potato gnocchi to the exquisite tiramisu, and the warm atmosphere made for a memorable dining experience.

07/07/2024 - Philly D.
Love their food!

08/16/2023 - MenuPix User
Best Italian food in the area. Makes me feel like back in Italy. Food is delicious. Service is great. I definitely recommend this ristorante ( magnifico)

11/05/2022 - Patricia Schiavone
Finally! A place where quality matters more than quantity. I grew up in Italy and it was back on memory lane for me. It is authentic Italian food, with a mixture of few different regions.
The portions are perfect. Unfortunately, if you are looking at quantity over quality, and dishes that are often not truly Italian either, more Americanized, this is not the place for you.

07/28/2022 - Vincenze
My heart hurts
Grew up at Detondo's, around the corner when it truly was a neighborhood place, was favorite place to go, after reading all the reviews the new owners should change the name of the place as it seems everything else has changed, I truly wish them luck, but a lot of us old timers will be looking for a new place to meet for lunch and drinks!

07/21/2022 - MenuPix User
Da best

03/16/2022 - harry
just can't believe these new people would not have the best sellers for lunch like delicous sausage sandwich

01/27/2022 - G Man
Lunch, house wine from a box, no red sauce ( wait a minute-Italian and zero sauce ) at all, can't sit at a table unless entire party arrives, must order & pay before sitting at find your own table, under seasoned food, 4-OZ water glass, had to re-fill myself, small portions, not even in the same country as the old DiTondo's. Party of 3 = $84.00 Went to Swanny House after and had a large bowl of excellent chili. California thinking won't work in Buffalo, NY.

12/25/2021 - MenuPix User
A group of us experienced DiTondo's for lunch this week and had an amazing meal. If you have traveled to Italy, you will appreciate the authentic Italian food brought to Buffalo even more. I enjoyed the open kitchen as we could watch the Chef and Lacy at the register did a good job of explaining the specials. A must go!

10/09/2021 - MenuPix User
Extremely expensive extremely small portions. Ok food nothing to rave about. Had to get pwn silverware water and clean up after self and they want a tip before you get your food. Crazy. It is roomy open quite a few people there maybe because new. Need more options no spaghetti or chicken parm really? Sadly i will not go back. Definitely not worth it was better with old owners

10/08/2021 - MenuPix User
Not what I expected no spaghetti parmn no bar nothing we liked