Captain Cookie and the Milkman

Popular Menu Items

• Ginger Molasses
• Chewy, puffy cookies with dark molasses flavor, spiced with cloves, cinnamon, and lots of ginger. Crowned with sugar for a crispy crust! Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
• Chocolate Chip
• This is how it all started. The Captain has been perfecting the recipe for these rich, chewy cookies studded with dark chocolate chips for over 20 years. Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel Air fryer - 2 minutes at 300 degrees Microwave - 10 seconds under a damp paper towel
• Oatmeal Raisin
• The classic. Chewy oats with just the right level of spice and a generous helping of plump raisins. Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
• Confetti
• Our sugar cookie, made 80% more fun with sprinkles! Tastes like a birthday party. Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
• Vegan Chocolate Chip
• The Captain churns our vegan butter from scratch - these cookies are a three-day process, and their amazing taste is the result of years of recipe-tweaking! Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel