Brothers Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

6746 W Gulf To Lake Hwy
Crystal River, FL 34429

Phone: (352) 564-9374

Website

Neighborhood: Crystal River

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Brothers Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Brothers Pizza

Write a Review

  4.4 stars - Based on 78 reviews

#28 out of 106 restaurants in Crystal River

#1 of 8 Pizza in Crystal River

5 star				46 reviews	59%
4 star				25 reviews	32%
3 star				3 reviews	4%
2 star				1 review	1%
1 star				3 reviews	4%

Top Reviews of Brothers Pizza

06/04/2024 - Jonathan S.
The spinach and mushroom pizza at this place is my absolute favorite, while my husband always goes for the classic cheese pizza. Despite the slightly above average quality of the food, the service was good and the takeout option is convenient for a food snob like me. The variety of dishes, such as the spaghetti and meatballs and the calzones, along with the friendly staff, keep me coming back to try new things and enjoy a great dining experience every time.

06/01/2024 - Zhang C.
Stunner

09/12/2023 - MenuPix User
awesome pizza Friday night should have taken a picture and it was delicious ....thank you

04/14/2023 - Judith Beeler
On time take out. Hot and ready. 3 appetizers all delicious.

04/29/2022 - David
Pizza, subs,Greek salads. Staff is friendly, too. Busy Lil place.

01/30/2022 - Bob
Best pizza within 50 miles

01/12/2022 - MenuPix User
Great pizza at a good price

10/13/2021 - MenuPix User
Good pizza, but also a lot of other selections. My favorite is a turkey roll. Food is consistently good, and service very personal.

10/03/2021 - Tom Davies
Best pizza around. HANDS DOWN!!!!

09/27/2021 - Steinhauer
This is the best pizza in "Citrus County ".

09/03/2021 - Karen
My neighbor bought pizza from here the other day and it's the best I've had in a while so I ordered a whole pie myself it's absolutely delicious

05/11/2021 - Brian
The best Steak n Cheese sandwiches...

02/18/2021 - Taylor
Always great food no matter what you order!

10/23/2020 - BC
Never a bad experience with this restaurant. I always order my orders as delivery because it's a block away from where I work and the delivery drivers are always very prompt and courteous. The pizza is delicious but my faves are their wraps and their salads. They always use fresh ingredients and they never skimp on anything.

09/25/2020 - Zelcolath
Best veggie pizza ever! Perfect crust...nice salads, too. Nice casual dining spot.

09/05/2020 - Kyle Wright
This place is hands down one of the most horrible pizza joints I have ever ordered from. The staff members are beyond rude and there is something wrong with the cheese they use on their pizza, it is NOT mozzarella. And if it is mozzarella it's the lowest grade mozzarella you can order - this is the same nasty grade cheese as hungry howies. Save your money and your tastebuds.

08/31/2020 - Connie Bishop
I like their food

07/27/2020 - Jim
Best pizza around all their food is delicious 👍😎

04/14/2020 - Mary Schlumberger
Great food. Thank you for continuing food availability.

04/13/2020 - Ken Gould
Brothers Pizza is my "go-to" choice for Pizza in Citrus County. I've eaten pizza at many places in Citrus County and we are blessed with a variety of good choices. But Brothers Pizza is the place I return to time and time again. Different people have different preferences in pizzas.

I am from Chicago, and I have a fondness for Chicago style pizza. So I ask for extra cheese on my Brothers Pizza. It comes close to the pizzas I remember in Chicago. The staff constantly changes, but the pizza recipe doesn't.

And the pizza is ready quickly. All in all, worth five stars.

04/12/2020 - MenuPix User
We ordered for pick-up tonight a simple medium thin crust cheese and it was terrible! Honestly, it tasted worse than a frozen pizza! I would have rather had pizza from the roller barn! Very disappointing!

04/08/2020 - Sam
Just wanted to say that the last guy that reviewed on March 27th is a douchebag. Who leaves a negative review during these times... Go back to New York as#$ole

03/27/2020 - NY NY
Looks and tastes like frozen pizza cheese. Absolutely terrible quality! I thought maybe this place could be good based on the reviews but now it just makes me wonder what are these people used to eating? Frozen style pizza , Wow!

05/30/2019 - MenuPix User
Wonderful food.....they give you large helpings. Always fresh and delicious. Great friendly service.

01/08/2019 - MenuPix User
Best pizza in town! Great service, friendly wait staff...you just can't go wrong!!

07/31/2018 - Julia B.
Small hole in the wall type pizza place. Order in at least once a week. Pizza is always hot and fresh tasting. Thankful the Brothers came here.

06/12/2016 - Terry Hodges
Excellent. They helped me select as it was my first time ordering from them. Pizza delicious. Also, they were right on time.

04/17/2016 - Ken
At one time they had the best pizza in the county. Now due to management /ownership change or whatever reason not so much. Dough is soggy due to not being cooked thoroughly and attitude as far as pick up orders are concerned is......we're doing you a favor.

12/07/2015 - Karen
Pizza was quite good, but do not order their "jumbo" chicken wings. The only thing jumbo about them is the amount of breading. The menu does not indicate they are breaded. We ordered the garlic parmesan cheese wings. They are battered and fried wings that are then saturated in minced garlic and sprinkled with parnesan. I bit into those bits of minced garlic. Disgusting. And I love garlic. Do it right or don't do it at all.