Vitale's Pizza Cellar

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

402 S Main St
Princeton, IL 61356

Phone: (815) 879-7671

Website

Neighborhood: Princeton

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Tu-Th: 11am-2pm & 4pm-11pm; F: 11am-2pm & 4pm-12am; Sa: 4pm-12am; Su: 4pm-11pm

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Vitale's Pizza Cellar

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Vitale's Pizza Cellar

Write a Review

  4.3 stars - Based on 65 reviews

#6 out of 37 restaurants in Princeton

#1 of 5 Pizza in Princeton

5 star				37 reviews	57%
4 star				20 reviews	31%
3 star				3 reviews	5%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				5 reviews	8%

Top Reviews of Vitale's Pizza Cellar

10/19/2024 - Maria R.
Stopped in last night for dinner and ordered a basic sausage and cheese pizza along with an order of cheese bread. Both dishes were absolutely delicious, with the pizza standing out as one of the best I've had in a long time. The service was exceptional, and the care and attention to detail from John, the owner, truly made the experience memorable.

05/25/2024 - Maureen C.
Brilliant

08/23/2023 - Julie
I have never had a bad pizza here, it's always wonderful!

07/20/2023 - Hope Carpintino
Only pizza I'll eat in princeton

04/02/2023 - tea bone
ooh yeah really good

05/29/2022 - Wilson
Always fantastic pizza

05/14/2022 - tim
best pizza ever

11/01/2021 - Brooklyn
The food is horrible I'm from Brooklyn New York I know food especially pizza pizza cellar is horrible I would rather have a dollar frozen pizza than the pizza cellar the beef is horrible the sandwiches are horrible I guess the people in Princeton will eat anything never ever will I go to pizza cellar I would rather starve

04/16/2021 - Rick b
Omg the pizza is amazing

04/02/2021 - MenuPix User
Love that pie

05/13/2020 - MenuPix User
I grew up in our beloved Princeton & very recently moved back H❤️ME from a Chicago western suburb. While there were some impressive ones, George's remains my favorite of all time!!! Growing up, my Dad always came home with a pizza on Friday nights. We looked forward to that all week long. To this very day, Friday (or Saturday when need be) night the tradition lives. Now, every Friday (or Saturday when need be) not only will it be pizza night, it will be George's pizza night. I am H❤️ME &
I am H❤️PPY!!!

05/16/2016 - Katie
Best pizza I've ever had in my life...the people that don't like it are probably used to eating crap from Pizza Hut! The cheese is fresh and the crust is thin & crisp. Wish they were open on Mondays!!

12/22/2015 - Steve
After waiting over an hour and calling twice,our food arrived COLD ( fries temped at 72 degrees)!!!!!! we were told we would be comped.Two days later and still no refund to bank account.
I will give just about any restaurant a chance to redeem themselves,and this was their last one.
The only reason we ordered that night was because Marias was closed for vacation.
To say this place is horrible would be giving them too much credit.
A sandwich from a gas station would be better,AND a whole lot cheaper!!!
AVOID THIS PLACE AT ALL COSTS!!!!!!
In order to post this I had to give them at least one star....wish I could take it back :(

03/10/2014 - Bobby
Anyone who likes this crap they call pizza is obviously a princeton sucker. Holy crap, I can't believe this town and it's food!!!

11/03/2012 - chickadee
We just had a pizza from here, and it SUCKED!!!!!!!!!!!!! The crust was burned, the sausage was half raw and it looked like crap. We will never eat there again!!!!!!!!!!

04/27/2012 - Myself
I had a terrible experience tonight at the pizza cellar. I got delivery but my pizza was terrible. It was really hard and hardly any toppings. But that happens, so i called to tell them and ask to have them make a new one. They were really rude on the phone. Thats the worst part. Sometimes people make bad pizzas on accident (and they DO have good pizza) so had they just remade it nicely it would have been fine. But, they had a bad attitude and were really mean on the phone. They did end up making us a new one..but they had the delivery guy come get the old one first and then it took them awhile to bring the new one back. I wont be going back there. Like there food normally, but hate their attitude!

09/11/2010 - tony
absolutely the best pizza ever, anywhere...ive tried them all, lol, and nobody comes close... id like to convince the owners to open a store in naples florida, they would make a fortune...just off me!

12/29/2009 - Joe Bestbamble
Best Pizza in the world.
Every time I'm back in town, I need to have my George's pizza

08/27/2009 - Cindy Duffield
Best Pizza in town. I haven't lived there for 30 years but every time I pass through Princeton I get a pizza from the Cellar.