Commander Cody's Seafood

4.3

21 reviews

#4 out of 16 restaurants in Shelter Island

($$), Seafood, Barbecue
Hours today: 11:00am-9:00pm

Add Review

Call

Website

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

41 Smith St
Shelter Island, NY 11964

Phone: (631) 749-1851

Neighborhood: Shelter Island

Update Listing

Bookmark Update Menus Edit Info Read Reviews Write Review

Hours

Open Today:

11:00am-9:00pm
Monday11:00am-8:00pm
Tuesday11:00am-8:00pm
Wednesday11:00am-8:00pm
Thursday11:00am-8:00pm
Friday11:00am-9:00pm
Saturday11:00am-9:00pm
Sunday11:00am-8:00pm

Update Hours

View the Menu

View Menus

Restaurant Details

Delivery
Yes

Payment
Cash Only

Parking

Good for Kids
Yes

Attire
Casual

Alcohol
No

Reservations
No

Cuisines:
Seafood, Barbecue

Price Point
$$

WiFi
No

Outdoor Seats
Yes

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

See Menus

Write a Review for Commander Cody's Seafood

Reviews for Commander Cody's Seafood

Write a Review

4.3 stars - Based on 21 reviews

#4 out of 16 restaurants in Shelter Island

#1 of 2 Seafood in Shelter Island

5 star	8 reviews	38%
4 star	11 reviews	52%
3 star	2 reviews	10%
2 star	0 reviews	0%
1 star	0 reviews	0%

Top Reviews of Commander Cody's Seafood

06/28/2024 - Jacy T.
Great food!

06/04/2024 - Missy H.
The seafood at Commander Cody's is absolutely delicious and fresh, with a variety of options to choose from. Be sure to call ahead to place your order and bring some extra cash to try out different dishes on the menu - it's definitely worth it!

08/27/2023 - Gary Gerth
Great seafood at affordable prices !!!!!

Best Menus of Shelter Island Best Menus of Long Island

Seafood Restaurants in Shelter Island Barbecue Restaurants in Shelter Island

Kyle's ($$)
Bakery, Bar, Diner, Breakfast
Distance: 0.34 miles

Planet Bliss ($$)
American
Distance: 0.36 miles

18 Bay Restaurant ($$$)
Italian
Distance: 0.36 miles

Bella Vita Pizza ($$)
Pizza
Distance: 0.46 miles

Shelter Island Craft Brewery ($$)
Breweries
Distance: 0.49 miles

Shelter Island Seafood ($)
Seafood, Seafood Markets

Vine Street Cafe ($$$)
Cafe, Sandwiches, American New, Italian, Asian Fusion

Salt Waterfront Bar & Grill ($$)
American, Gastropubs, Bar Food

Shelter Island Craft Brewery ($$)
Breweries

L'uccello Pizza & Italian Fare (Greenlawn, NY)

I discovered an incredible restaurant that offers a unique dining experience. The atmosphere is inviting, and the menu features a fantastic selection ... see review

Serra Provisions (Port Washington, NY)

I discovered a fantastic restaurant that truly impressed me. The atmosphere was vibrant, and the food was absolutely delicious. It’s a must-try for ... see review

Armin & Judy (Bridgehampton, NY)

You absolutely have to check out this incredible destination that offers a captivating blend of culture and adventure. Its vibrant atmosphere and rich... see review

Val Brook Diner Restaurant (Valley Stream, NY)

This diner is our family's favorite for delicious food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere.... see review

Princess Deli (Commack, NY)

I rarely share my thoughts, but this deli has become my daily lunch destination, consistently impressing me with its exceptional food and warm, welcom... see review

View Menus

Commander Cody's Seafood
Home
Long Island
Long Island
Shelter Island

Long Island Restaurant Guide: See Menus, Ratings and Reviews for Restaurants in Long Island and New York

United States Restaurant Guide:

AK | AL | AR | AZ | CA | CT | CO | DE | FL | GA | HI | ID | IL | IN | IA | KS | KY | LA | MD | ME | MA | MI | MN | MS | MO | MT | NC | ND | NE | NV | NH | NJ | NM | NY | OH | OK | OR | PA | RI | SC | SD | TN | TX | UT | VT | VA | WA | WV | WI | WY

Canadian Major Cities and Provinces:

Most Popular US City Guides:

Commander Cody's Seafood

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Commander Cody's Seafood

Reviews for Commander Cody's Seafood

Top Reviews of Commander Cody's Seafood

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

Commander Cody's Seafood

Location and Contact

Hours

View the Menu

Restaurant Details

Restaurant Description

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Commander Cody's Seafood

Reviews for Commander Cody's Seafood

Top Reviews of Commander Cody's Seafood

Best Restaurants Nearby

Nearby Restaurants

Menus People Viewed Nearby

Recent Restaurant Reviews

Oops, we can't find your location