Carlitos' Cafe

Popular Menu Items

• Mulitas $14.99
• Choice of fajita beef, chicken, pork, carnitas, tio's guiso and chorizo, with onions, cilantro, avocado and cheese.
• Fajita Lunch $15.99
• Beef, chicken or mixed fajitas, rice, refried beans, pico de gallo, guacamole and sour cream.
• Taco Salad Lunch $11.99
• Ground beef, shredded beef or shredded chicken, refried beans, lettuce tomatoes, cheese, onions, black olives, guacamole and sour cream.
• Cheese Enchilada Lunch $7.99
• Corn or flour tortilla filled with cheese, choice of lite, regular, or large serving. Sauce options include cheese, chili, and more. Served with two sides from a selection of nine options.
• Chimichanga Lunch $11.99
• Cheese, beef or chicken fajita chunks, with choice of sauce, rice and refried beans.

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

622 NW 32nd St
Newcastle, OK 73065

Phone: (405) 387-3500

Website

Neighborhood: Newcastle

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Carlitos' Cafe

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Carlitos' Cafe

Write a Review

  3.6 stars - Based on 51 reviews

#2 out of 40 restaurants in Newcastle

#2 of 5 Mexican in Newcastle

5 star				11 reviews	22%
4 star				24 reviews	47%
3 star				9 reviews	18%
2 star				1 review	2%
1 star				6 reviews	12%

Top Reviews of Carlitos' Cafe

07/09/2024 - Kris T.
Dreamy!

05/01/2024 - Sandi M.
I recently dined at Carlito's and indulged in the chorizo and fajita chicken tacos, which were delectable. The server was incredibly kind, and the ambiance, with soothing Christmas music in the background, provided a much-needed escape. I look forward to returning to Carlito's for their consistently delicious and well-seasoned dishes.

10/04/2021 - Sherri Williams McDonald
My family and I love Carlitos.
The food and drinks are always good.
Usually good, fast service.
I drive from far SE OKC to eat there.

07/30/2021 - MenuPix User
Buyer be ware. When you order fajitas be careful. Your food may not be what you ordered and you are charged for their mistake. In our case our bill was 3 times what we ordered. Manager was rude and would not compromise or talk to waiter. Communication seemed to be an issue. Will not be back. Can't afford it. They need to be reported to better business bureau. Looked at other reviews. Looks like ongoing problem.

01/16/2021 - Crystal
We use to love Carito's. I ordered a chicken enchilada and a shredded beef enchilada dinner. The sour cream on the chicken enchilada was terrible the chicken had no flavor The chili on the beef enchilada terrible. My husband fajitas were cold. Tasted like they were cooked in a microwave. This use to be our favorite Mexican restaurant. NOT ANYMORE! Not sure what happened, but we will never come here again.

10/05/2020 - MenuPix User
Good food, just a little pricey. Staff is excellent but being in a small town, need to consider prices.

03/01/2019 - stan
excellent, the best in tri city area

11/28/2018 - Mary C.
Horrible place to eat. I ate there and got extremely sick. I ordered chicken fajitas they wasnt sizzling when they was brought out to me. I set there with an empty glass half way through my dinner. It was a very bad experience I will not be back.

10/31/2018 - MenuPix User
So we ( my job ) ordered food from here, & it was AWFUL! I called the manager to complain & he actually told me to go to La Lunas next time, & that he never has complaints. I know that is a lie because I have complained before. This USE to be a good place to eat , but it has gone down hill! Who tells you to go somewhere else just because he ( the mgr ) doesn't want to do his job!!!!

08/12/2018 - Jonathan G.
Some of these reviews are a little harsh. Food was very good.

10/24/2017 - Pat-Yukon, OK
By far the worst example of Tex-Mex or so called Mexican food. Has the worst service to go along with your meal. Prices are outrageous, my wife ordered 1 taco and a diet soda almost 12 bucks!! One of the other people at the table received the wrong order and they wouldn't even correct it? They actually said she would have to pay for it because it would be a waste? This place does not even deserve 1 star, Salsa tastes like can of tomatoes with no flavor. Please drive into OKC, Moore or Norman before you waste your time or money here. Congrats Carlitos' you now have the distinction of being the absolute worst food and quality of service around. Keep up the bad work.

10/09/2014 - Robin Berryman
We love to eat there! The food is always great and the service exceptional! It is our "Go TO place of choice. Friendly atmosphere with great food. We have never had to wait longer than 20 minutes to be seated and served.

03/29/2014 - Rich
ordered a double beef fajitas, special with no onions, i am alergic to them, and wanted extra green bell peppers, i recived a box with beef (kinda) and a sh-t load of onions, and no peppers at all the poppers i orderd were 1 short, the person on the phone understood what i wanted and when my wife picked them up she repeated it back, of course when she got home this is what i got, i called in talked to manager (not good english speaking) said thats what i ordered, they just suck , he told me to keep it, i told him im alergic he did not understand what that was,i would not go there for any food, if they cant speak good enough english to make your food they cant uunderstand what you want either, piss poor resturant.