The Elias Cole

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

1176 State Rt 23
Sussex, NJ 07461

Phone: (973) 875-3550

Neighborhood: Sussex

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Casual Country style Restaurant in business for Over forty five years…

Restaurant Photos

See More Photos

 See All Photos

See All Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for The Elias Cole

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for The Elias Cole

Write a Review

  4.3 stars - Based on 64 reviews

#4 out of 38 restaurants in Sussex

#2 of 7 American in Sussex

5 star				32 reviews	50%
4 star				25 reviews	39%
3 star				5 reviews	8%
2 star				1 reviews	2%
1 star				1 reviews	2%

Top Reviews of The Elias Cole

06/24/2024 - Korey P.
very good

08/06/2023 - Berni Rauch
Best home cooked meals for more than 50+ years anywheres!!!!!! Yummy ❣️

01/11/2023 - Bernie
I love eating here for several reasons, the servers, the food, the atmosphere, the prices.

11/04/2022 - MenuPix User
Great food great pies try their beef barley soup

03/26/2022 - Lori
Always good. Best home made food and pies all done on premises l

12/20/2021 - Tina Gordon
A cozy friendly atmosphere. I used to go a few years ago when I went to High Point Park. It just a bit further down. Home made pies and soups are awesome, you get good portions of fresh tasty food and fabulous prices
Worth the trip. A real diamond in the rough!

10/09/2021 - Art & Suzanne D
Our favorite stop to eat! We are regulars - about once a week. We've had breakfast, lunch and dinner here!! Each meal has been 5 stars in every area of grading a restaurant!
Good old fashioned homemade food with a loving, friendly atmosphere.
The owners and workers are so friendly and exceptional as well!
We've never had anything we don't like!
The country setting on a rural road across from the sheep farm gives an added provincial quality. You can often see the sheep grazing.

06/29/2021 - Marilyn P.
Excellent food & service

03/14/2021 - MenuPix User
Home cooked type food, atmosphere, love the meatloaf, not fresh vegetables, wonderful thick white bread,

08/15/2020 - MenuPix User
Awesome Soups & Burgers!

12/26/2019 - John
I come here often before activities at High Point State Park. The food is high quality and the service is warm and friendly. Have to remember to bring cash and no choice of bread, besides their excellent homemade
Regards,
John - Nordic Ski Patroller and Hike Leader

02/27/2019 - Nancy M.
My parents had property in Wantage, NJ many many years ago & Elias Cole was our favorite restaurant. The food is absolutely delish. Homemade bread & pies absolutely YUMMY !!! I need to take a road trip soon.

Menu