Cutillo's Restaurant

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

1196 Farmers Mills Rd
Carmel, NY 10512

Phone: (845) 225-8903

Website

Neighborhood: Carmel

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Cutillo's Restaurant

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Cutillo's Restaurant

Write a Review

  4.5 stars - Based on 25 reviews

#23 out of 68 restaurants in Carmel

#3 of 5 Italian in Carmel

5 star				15 reviews	60%
4 star				9 reviews	36%
3 star				0 reviews	0%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				1 review	4%

Top Reviews of Cutillo's Restaurant

06/29/2024 - Celina S.
The food is always great.

07/08/2022 - Mike Diaz
I took my mom there for lunch and desperately wanted to like the place. It's tucked into a nice glen with green trees and pretty country setting. But that's where all the good stuff ends. The place smelled like diapers upon walking in. The servers and clientele were all over 80 years old and very slow. The SPECIAL app, Prosciutto and melon, was an unripe melon and spoiled GREENISH prosciutto. I thought it was the lighting until a bite confirmed the rancidness of the meat! Then (eventually) they brought out two tiny salads that were lightly sprinkled with brown and drying lettuce. To make matters worse the small plates they sat on were DIRTY-unodentified brown stuff was caked onto the plates!!!! Disgusting! That's saying something because I can (and will) out up with a lot! We didn't stay to see what our entrees might have been. They could've been great but between the lousy service, spoiled food and dirty plates and an hour waiting time, enough was enough and we left. If you're from the DOH, I recommend you shut this place down and be a pro to the community, you can and will save a life!

04/19/2020 - Francis mulvey
GREAT AS ALWAYS. VERY FRIENDLY AND COOPERATIVE.

12/03/2018 - Stephanie Principe
Everything is amazing . They only use the freshest ingredients. It is family owned & operated for many many years . Great service, delicious food , what more can you ask for .

06/04/2010 - Mike
Great food. Been here numerous times, never had a bad meal. Great and I mean GREAT steak. Fantastic service and extremely accommodating.