Eldred Preserve Restaurant

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

1040 State Route 55
Eldred, NY 12732

Phone: (845) 557-8316

Website

Neighborhood: Eldred

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Eldred Preserve Restaurant

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Eldred Preserve Restaurant

Write a Review

  4.0 stars - Based on 25 reviews

#2 out of 7 restaurants in Eldred

#1 of 3 American in Eldred

5 star				7 reviews	28%
4 star				13 reviews	52%
3 star				3 reviews	12%
2 star				1 reviews	4%
1 star				1 reviews	4%

Top Reviews of Eldred Preserve Restaurant

03/03/2025 - Brandt A.
If you're heading to Bethel Woods, a stop at this charming destination is a must. The serene setting by a lake and stream creates a beautiful backdrop, perfect for enjoying delicious appetizers and drinks by the gas fireplace. With friendly staff and a cozy atmosphere, it's an inviting spot for both casual hangouts and special occasions.

07/15/2024 - Dorothy M.
Always good!

06/28/2021 - Raised my Expections...too much
The building and landscape were nicely developed, in and out..I'd give it 5 star. But that's all you should expect.
The food is not even close to the rated establishment. Noting special. Poor desert menu. Stuff is inexperienced. Will think again before come back.

05/25/2021 - MenuPix User
This restaurant should not have opened until it had more time to train.
The staff is young and untrained. The restaurant was only half full and the waitstaff could not keep up.
When you have to wait over 20 minutes for a glass of ice, you know something is wrong.
The meat is of a good quality after you remove half the salt from the top. The mashed potatoes were ice cold and the cream spinach was bland but again very salty. The deserts were a complete waste of money. Pecan pie was very dry that you needed a large glass of milk, and the banana cream pie was a complete mess. Some people got the coconut shrimp with the sauce and some didn't. Is anyone overseeing the orders going out. When you spend this kind of money, you have high expectations, and this place just does not cut it. Next time I'm going to the beautiful bar and having a burger.