Broadway Pizza

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

462 Broadway
Monticello, NY 12701

Phone: (845) 791-7200

Website

Neighborhood: Monticello

Update Listing

Popular Menu Items

• Pepperoni Pie $14.00
• Dozen Wings (boneless) $11.00
• Hot, mild, BBQ or Honey, Honey BBQ, Garlic Parm
• Garlic Knots $4.00
• Mozzarella Sticks (4) $5.00
• With french fries.
• 10 Piece Wings (regular) $12.00
• Hot, mild, BBQ or Honey, Honey BBQ, Garlic Parm.

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Broadway Pizza

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Broadway Pizza

Write a Review

  3.8 stars - Based on 49 reviews

#29 out of 73 restaurants in Monticello

#4 of 13 Pizza in Monticello

5 star				13 reviews	27%
4 star				20 reviews	41%
3 star				11 reviews	22%
2 star				3 reviews	6%
1 star				2 reviews	4%

Top Reviews of Broadway Pizza

02/08/2025 - Judah P.
This little restaurant has fantastic food with generous portions and reasonable prices, making it my go-to for takeout since I moved here a year ago. Their pizza is delicious, and the eggplant rollatini is a standout-perfectly cooked with fresh eggplant and amazing sauce, definitely some of the best I've had since living in the Catskills.

06/08/2024 - Rosalia U.
Good Food

10/22/2021 - Doesn’t matter
Terrible people. Inconsiderate and rude. Would never eat here again, were it the last place on earth to eat. Would rather starve.

12/16/2020 - MenuPix User
Every time I go to Broadway Pizza it's a problem, first time I went there I ordered a pie and I wanted a 2 liter soda, the soda was $4 plus tax. ln the supermarket it cost $1.35, I know it's not the same thing but think about itand I didn't purchase it . Another time I ordered a slice the the store owner was picking the slice up with his hands after he's touching his phone after he's counting money with other people. I asked him to get another slice and he told me do I want this slice or not he was not going to give me a different slice. I'm just letting you know my experience there I don't feel that anyone should be touching any food especially in these days and time with their hands without gloves

03/17/2018 - Ahmed mahmoud
One of the best pizza places I been too the food is so delicious I have to go there at least 3 times a week me and my friends plus the sandwiches they make so fresh and eatable.