Carlinis Pizza Shop

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

4010 Central Ave
Shadyside, OH 43947

Phone: (740) 671-2100

Neighborhood: Shadyside

Update Listing

Hours

Sorry, we don't have hours for this restaurant yet. We'll be updating the hours for this restaurant soon.

Monday: Add Hours
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:
Saturday:
Sunday:

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Carlinis Pizza Shop

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Carlinis Pizza Shop

Write a Review

  4.5 stars - Based on 26 reviews

#2 out of 10 restaurants in Shadyside

#1 of 3 Pizza in Shadyside

5 star				17 reviews	65%
4 star				6 reviews	23%
3 star				2 reviews	8%
2 star				0 reviews	0%
1 star				1 review	4%

Top Reviews of Carlinis Pizza Shop

02/01/2025 - Celina H.
The Ohio Valley style pizza here is phenomenal, and it's certainly among the best in the area. While the subs are also quite good, I've consistently found the pizza to be exceptional, though I do hope the staff can improve their friendliness during pickup.

08/23/2024 - MenuPix User
we always order your subs .hot when we get them.your staff is very polite and well mannered.keep up the good work

11/01/2023 - MenuPix User
Do not follow these menus on line. The prices are way off. I ordered a couple of pizzas and thought the cost was gonna be 35 dollars and when it arrived it was over 49 dollars. I called carlinis and was told those were their old prices and they had no way to adjust them, pull them or update them.
I of course called b-llsh-t, but they did not even offer an apology. I would of sent it back but my kids had already started eating it. In their favor was the pizza was really good. I just don't like feeling like I was taken advantage of.

02/12/2023 - Sue Parker
Wonderful pizza

11/17/2022 - Jeffery Finnicum
The service is awesome! the food is awesome and the drinks are nice and cold. I am friends with the owners.

02/24/2022 - Dylan Krol
Rude. Incompetent. Unapologetic.

On February 18th, 2022 I purchased two slices of pepperoni to go from this establishment. Two days later my debit card was charged "$12.50".

Upon review of my card statement i could only assume the charges were a mistake as $12.50 for two slices of pepperoni pizza would be an absolutely ludicrous price.

On February 24th 2022 around 2' oclock I visited Carlini's Pizza to bring the improper charges to thier attention. Upon entering i asked to speak to a manager in a polite manner and made sure to maintain a proper demeanor. A rather well-aged blonde woman stepped forward and told me she was the owner.

I showed her the charges on my phone and informed her of my order and that I was under the impression the charges must have been a mistake.

I was asked a series of illogical questions absolutely irrelevant to the matter at hand such as "Did I get extra cheese?" and "Was I sure I used my debit card that day?"

I was told that she wasn't going to "just give me 10 dollars" without speaking to her manager to verify that what i was saying was correct. I couldn't help but feel i was accused of being dishonest.

The owner told me that the manager was supposed to be in at 2 oclock but was late today and asked if "I was going to be walking around town" (it's a chilly February day however I digress) to come back in 30 minutes.

I returned a half hour later to her manager and the owner counting the register on the front desk. She tells him "this is the kid." Luckily for me the manager remebered my order and in return for my rather large inconvenience the owner of this establishment hands me a crumbled, tore up ten dollar bill. She was entirely unapologetic and i was offered nothing in return for the "almost" theft of my last ten dollars other than a timid "sorry" . This is an absolutely abhorrent way to run a business.

I urge the brothers and sisters of Shadyside to spend thier money in more kind and compassionate businesses. Thank you.

***UPDATE***
A short while after posting the above review on the Carlini's Pizza Facebook page while resting on a public park bench the owner of this establishment found it acceptable and in good taste to pull over in a one-way street while performing an illegal traffic maneuver to harass and shout obscenities to me. I told her to leve me alone and that I did not want her harrassment.

I can only assyme that her anger stems from my valid public exposure of her unfair and dishonest business practices. I encourage any and all recent customers to *DOUBLE-CHECK* any debit or credit transactions made at this restaurant.

Also any potential customers or business partners PLEASE BE WELL-ADVISED of this woman's behavior.

02/19/2022 - MenuPix User
Best pizza I've ever had. When I go to Florida to visit family, I usually take two trays with me because they and their friends love it too. They call it "Ohio Valley style pizza".

04/21/2020 - MenuPix User
Best Pizza in town !!

07/31/2018 - Amanda K.
We go here when we're visiting my brother in Shadyside. The pizza is so good, I love the crust here so much.

08/28/2015 - Tristen
Cheapest, fastest, and best pizza in the valley.

Menu