Nino's 2 Tomato

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

2409 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105

Phone: (724) 658-3380

Website

Neighborhood: New Castle

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Nino's 2 Tomato

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Nino's 2 Tomato

Write a Review

  4.2 stars - Based on 39 votes

#5 out of 149 restaurants in New Castle

#1 of 22 Pizza in New Castle

5 star				16 votes	41%
4 star				19 votes	49%
3 star				1 votes	3%
2 star				0 votes	0%
1 star				3 votes	8%

Top Reviews of Nino's 2 Tomato

07/10/2024 - Sab B.
awesome place

10/09/2021 - MenuPix User
Two Tomatoes offers a great ambiance but do not care about their customers. We had our wedding rehearsal dinner here, we reserved the room over two months in advance and picked our meal with set prices prior to the event. Two days before the event, the owner calls us and says the price of meat has gone up and we have to pay the difference even though prices were already set. They also told us we could not change our mind about the menu because they already bought the meat for our buffet, regardless of the price change. Additionally, they would not cooperate with us, they seem nice and concerning about food allergies and dietary restrictions on the phone, but when can down to the meal they didn't do anything and people in our party could not eat because of it, and we still had to pay for them... Continuing they skipped an entire course of our meal and argued with us when said we didn't receive it, all food came out lukewarm or cold. The buffet was family style and they said we could have as much as we want of a certain dish but when asked, they said they couldn't give us more. Then to top it all off it was karaoke night, and we endure that our entire dinner even though we were in a "private room". Please do not go here, it is not worth your time unless it's the last option, the owner even told us he could not help us in any way when we were very disappointed because by putting the customer-first he would have to close his doors.

10/06/2021 - MenuPix User
Always a great experience whether online on in person

11/02/2020 - MenuPix User
Were you located anywhere else in New Castle...southside, northhill ??

07/16/2020 - MenuPix User
I love your food i only come a few times and i think Tracey waited on me she did a wonderful job

08/25/2019 - Julianne
A+ for atmosphere. A+ for service. A+ for food quality. Oh - if you're lucky enough to be there when it's available ... Lemon Cheesecake!

11/14/2016 - Dianne
I wanted to view the menu online but couldn't,. This sounds about right for this place, an average menu, a very poor wine selection, an intolerable decibel level and high prices. Color me gone and not coming back.

10/22/2016 - BUTCH WOMER
I'm fron California this is the best of the best strongly recommend , I eat there every time I'm in town to visit 😎

05/08/2016 - jd
WORST mothers day PLACE EVER, i go to there so called buffet, i wanted to try the ham and pasta, so i grab just alittle of each to see if i like it, and right away the waitress takes my plate and silverware and brings me my bill, WOW really, so its not a 20 dollar buffet, its 20 a plate, and charged 18 percent tip, and was charged 52 dollars for 2 people, I WOULD NEVER EAT THERE OR RECOMMED THAT PLACE TO ANYONE!!! ya rob you on mothers day, what a joke, after going there i went home and made dinner for my wife and i, after i just spent 50 on that joke of a place. DO NOT EAT THERE, IT IS A JOKE AND THEY WILL ROB U

Menu