Paddy Cake Bakery

Add Review

Call

Website

Menu

Location and Contact

See Map - Get Directions

4763 Liberty Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15224

Phone: (412) 621-4477

Website

Neighborhood: Pittsburgh

Update Listing

Hours

Update Hours

View the Menu

Update Details

Restaurant Description

Add a description here.

Restaurant Photos

View Menu

Write a Review for Paddy Cake Bakery

Share Your
Experience!

Select a Rating Select a Rating!

Reviews for Paddy Cake Bakery

Write a Review

  3.9 stars - Based on 23 reviews

#376 out of 2537 restaurants in Pittsburgh

#6 of 96 Bakery in Pittsburgh

5 star				7 reviews	30%
4 star				11 reviews	48%
3 star				2 reviews	9%
2 star				2 reviews	9%
1 star				1 review	4%

Top Reviews of Paddy Cake Bakery

04/13/2025 - Ya J.
This bakery offers a wide variety of delicious baked goods, and the friendly staff enhances the experience. I appreciate the reasonable prices and the nostalgic ambiance, reminiscent of classic neighborhood bakeries. During my visits, I've consistently enjoyed their donuts, cakes, and other treats, making it a favorite destination for my family and me.

11/22/2024 - Israel M.
I enjoy visiting this bakery because of their early opening hours, allowing me to grab delicious donuts and cupcakes for my colleagues before work. The friendly staff and exceptional quality of the baked goods make this bakery a favorite spot for me.

07/02/2024 - Anna G.
food was good

04/17/2023 - HairBySamDiane
The three woman working the day I had went there were all super friendly and nice. It was the day before Easter and we stopped in from being at the hospital. It was so nice to grab fresh air and fresh bake goodies. There was so much to choose and pick from. The decor on the baked goods were super cute and I was obsessed with my dipped chocolate peep. The pineapple upside down cake was good even a few days later. I can't wait to come back. This place is amazing, ten stars, price is fair and so good too.

My husband and I will definitely be back and tell family & friends about this place.

10/20/2022 - MenuPix User
Love this place the employees were soonice.went here to get my husband a treat for his birthday while he was in hospital. They were wonderful and soo was his cakes

09/05/2021 - MenuPix User
I heard such great reviews and traveled over thirty minutes to pick my cake up. I was so excited"¦..my birthday celebration took a bad turn. Did the baker not taste the batter? Did they forget the butter in the buttercream frosting. I have a big cake of nothingness and the only thing I taste was from purple food coloring. I am taking it back and contacts
my bank concerning their theft of service! I ordered a cake and got a box of iced flour! A cake from Sams Club would have been better"¦..NEVER AGAIN!

07/04/2021 - MenuPix User
A family member ordered cupcakes and thumbprints for a 6-26-21 small grad party. The icing in school colors of green and white was swirled almost flat. The white ones were pretty tasty, the chocolate ones, however, were dry and seemed stale or old. She ordered and paid for 3 dozen (and when the person picking them up got home with the order) there were only two dozen! The thumbprints weren't very fresh either!

Both of these items were top notch at one time, but Paddy Cake has gone down hill a good bit over the past couple of years. They need to get back to whatever worked previously.

06/09/2021 - Tonya
My Girl friend brought two different birthday cakes from them for my 65th birthday get together with family and friends , one of which had a picture on it from when we were 13 years old , a beautiful memory , the other was a regular birthday cake . Upon serving the Regular cake , my guest were making remarks and a out burst of laughter pursued . When we really found out what was happening they said the cake is hard . This was unacceptable . Paddy cake is known for there service so I don't know what really happened her. Was these cakes left over from the Memorial Day cakes ? Then when she came to there store on the next business day they gave her the run around and try to blame it on her. These cakes were never open , they left the store and arrived at my home . Get it together Paddy cake . You ruined my birthday Celebration.