Reviews for Papa Pete's Pizza

05/26/2022 - Kris Kelly
The F***ing place is closed!!! I drove an hour to get there because the website said it was open, I was very pissed!!

12/31/2014 - Jean
Absolutely the worst service and worst pizza I have ever had and felt like I had been robbed after waiting for the pizza and tasting it. So bad, 2 grandchildren that eat everything spit it out and ate only the Pepperoni.
We walked in for the very first and last time. Walked up to the counter where the girl fixing the pizza looked at us and went right back to working. Same with the girl sweeping the floor while the pizza's were being made. A young man looked over and kept working. Finally the girl with the broom told another young man we might need some help. We asked about seating and were told to seat ourselves and we could order when we were ready. We did, 1 large, 1 small, 1 salad and 4 16 ounce non-refillable drinks...$51+change.

It took 15 minutes to get the salad. It was fresh, the dressing good. Another 20 minutes to get 1 of 2 cold pizza's. The 2nd one had another wait on it because their oven messed it up was what we were told. Grands said the crust would be better if it were cardboard because then they could taste it.

By the time my pizza arrived, I wanted to go home. Don't let all the cars in the parking lot fool you, pretty sure they belong to the Mexican restaurant in the same parking lot. Eat there, it has to be better food. Then again, even Taco Bell is better than this place.

10/15/2014 - Sharon Ellis
I reserved a table for 10 on Friday the 11th. It was a special occasion with people who really wanted to enjoy good pizza and fun. I reserved for 5:00, they asked me to have my order placed by 4:00 so they could start it at the appropriate time and it would be done just when we needed it. We got there and it was very unorganized, we waited a while, finally told where to sit. We waited quite a while until I finally went up to see what the problem was, my pizza was in "to-go" boxes kept in the warmer!! They had no clue why they were there, they gave me the boxes and we sat down with pizza's that were in there so long they were not only barely warm, but the lettuce on the taco pizza was already wilty. I said nothing, paid the bill, which by the was just a few dollars short of 100.00 for 3 pizzas. I didn't want to ruin the evening, so we all went to my house for cake and ice-cream. When everyone left I called them to explain how the meal had gone. The girl said "she knew there had been a mistake and was sorry, that if I came in again she hoped it would be better". Seriously, I just spent nearly 100.00 for the worst pizza with the worst customer service ever. I don't care to ever go back, and I believe they should have bent over backwards and at least offerd a free pizza to the party girl who so graciously ignored the bad service and food. wow!!!!!

06/29/2013 - Ed Kraus
Overpriced. Slow. Charged extra to put it in a box! Kicker though, watching the employee "mopping" the top of the pizza with a paper towel? WTH!