Reviews for Erdey's Sandwich Shop

08/20/2024 - Alycia D.
Nat Albany's Italian heritage shines through in the delicious offerings at this local eatery. The no-frills service model allows for a quick and efficient dining experience. The homemade sandwiches, juicy burgers, and crispy fries are a must-try for anyone passing through town.

04/24/2024 - Cherry N.
Charming!

03/21/2023 - MenuPix User
Got to many high school kids working there plus they are soo rude on the phone. I placed an order on the phone to pickup, the kid on the phone read the order back to me plus gave me the amount. When I showed up to pickup my order, after driving 30 minutes to get there, I went thru 4 kids at the window before one told me there was not an order placed in my name. With that I left & never been back. Poor management.

03/20/2019 - David Roberts
Had excellent customer service and an amazing shrimp po boy, Crystal was more than happy to take my order with a smile!

08/04/2018 - Olivia D.
Great sandwich shop plus more.

06/28/2017 - Amy
I love this place!

06/01/2016 - Debbie
Johnny Erdy salad is the bomb!!! I drive all the from Greensburg for it!

03/28/2015 - kk
My fave is the club sandwich

10/08/2013 - Elaine
Wanted to try since I was told they had great food with a previous restaurant they owned .
Unfortunately for us the bread on the hamburger porboys were too tuff to bite. It was the same texture as if it had been put in a microwave. The french fries were soggy and cold also! Very dissappointed !

08/14/2013 - ellen forbes
Went for lunch.my husband got a burger. I got a johnny erdey salad .both were very good. We will be going back.so come try it you wont be dissapointed.