Reviews for Old Hickory Steakhouse

07/22/2024 - Chris E.
Old Hickory Steak House offers a straightforward yet excellent dining experience, focusing on quality over variety. The menu is simple, featuring a selection of four steak cuts served with a salad, baked potato, and garlic bread, ensuring a satisfying and delicious meal for steak lovers.

06/02/2024 - Santiago M.
Great food and service.

12/27/2022 - MenuPix User
The best steak EVER!

11/14/2021 - jeff
LITERALLY THE BEST STEAK EVER...
I work in Columbus twice a year at steel dynamics plant... First place I go when get into town and the lady place I go before I leave..👍

01/29/2019 - J.Rider
Always great. Always punctual. In and out less than an hour. Love it !

02/12/2017 - greg stanfill
saturday Feb 11 2017. Our family got there at 8:00PM, had to stand in line, no problem. I have eaten here all my life. Salad an drinks right on time. My salad was not cold but did not complain. the tea was great as always . She left the tea jug on table an i loved that. When our steaks got there ONE HOUR AND FIFTEEN MINUTES LATER, i was upset to say the least. One of the ribeyes looked like the sole of a shoe. The tender part on the edge was not there, that is the best part. the other stakes were a plate full. It looked like a NY strip. She said it was a ribeye with out all of the fat. BULL!!! This was a special night for our family i had to keep my mouth closed, wife kicking me under table. We Know Marty an Hope by name they are always super nice. The cook was not the same guy. My stake did not taste the same. This is the second time with ribeye with no fat. We did not complain, left a big tip. But will not be back.

11/01/2013 - Gunner
Totally awesome steak!!! If I could I'd eat there everyday!