Reviews for Angelina's Italian Kitchen

03/18/2025 - Jesus P.
I checked out Angelina's for the first time recently and was blown away by their cheese pizza and homemade chocolate chip cookies. Everything was fresh and delicious, and the family running the place is fantastic, making it a must-visit for anyone craving great New York-style pizza.

06/27/2024 - Greg T.
Real good food

09/25/2021 - Not a fan anymore
Was a great pizza place when it first opened. So, so now. After almost 3 months of messages saying they're closed and having to wait 1 1/2 hours to pick up, will be the last time. First, significant price increase. Understand price increases are happening everywhere but this was way more than expected. Could accept but-----paying a lot more for way less---no thanks. The crust is half the original thickness. Can almost read through it and like chewing rubber toward the outside edge. About 2 tablespoons of sauce spread on the whole thing. Half the volume of toppings. About half the slices were almost bare. Asked for extra cheese. Shouldn't have wasted the money but if I didn't ask for the extra cheese, pretty sure I wouldn't have gotten any at all. Overall taste was not as good as it used to be. Oh, and lets not forget the Exact time you are supposed to be there. They are charging you an additional $2.50 to look at the pick up time on your ticket.

09/23/2021 - MenuPix User
Best Pizza in the Annapolis/Edgewater area by far!!!!

09/05/2021 - MenuPix User
Great food

08/21/2021 - Local Resident
Loved Angelina's pizza. Was a weekly regular. However, they are always closed when we call. Saturday is the only day we've been able to get through. So frustrated that it's not worth trying anymore. Although not nearly as good, we have been ordering from the local chain shops for several months now. Their loss. Not even recommending to friends anymore either.

08/15/2020 - MenuPix User
No answer when I called it was a sat. afternoon .... VERY DISAPOINTING !

04/25/2020 - Danielle Bafkas
At 11AM, April 23, I was meeting my sister in Denton. Stopped at A for pizza,NYC. They'd just opened and were slammed. One plain cheese, one pepperoni. I guess to rush, the crusts were undercooked like an under done cookie. I've had her pizza; I grew up in NYC so, yes, sadly, we were disappointed.

03/02/2020 - Andy G
The pizza is as close to NY pizza as you'll find, and the meatball parmesan HERO ( that's NY for SUB) was delicious, I'll definitely be returning there for a taste of home 👌