Reviews for Parthenon Coney Island

04/23/2024 - Jesse G.
Our Lincoln Park High School Class of June 1967 recently gathered for an alumni breakfast at the Parthenon, where we received exceptional service from the staff, including the owner, Eddie. The restaurant offers a variety of daily specials, such as braised lamb shank, jumbo shrimp, and pork chops. The Greek salad is fresh and the pita bread is of high quality, although I did encounter an issue with my gummy and burnt rye toast. Despite this, the overall experience at Parthenon was enjoyable, with fast and friendly service, delicious food, and reasonable prices that keep customers coming back.

12/04/2020 - MenuPix User
I am trying to be understanding because I know we are in the middle of a pandemic and I realize restaurants are being hit particularly hard, but I really think this place just lost a loyal customer. I work midnights and I stop here after work about three days a week because I don't feel like cooking after being on my feet for 12 hours. On this particular occasion, I was given rotten broccoli and eggs over hard. I ordered them over easy. No big deal, right? I'll call them and ask if I can get my order fixed. Nope! When I called, the young waitress who is very rude by the way, cuts me off in the middle of my explanation and puts me on hold without saying anything. The manager picks up the phone and tells me they just opened the broccoli so there was no way it was rotten and it turns that color because they put it on the grill. Does it also smell like garbage because they grill it? No. It smells and looks like that because it is ROTTEN. He also informed me that my eggs were cooked the exact way I specified. He read my order back to me and said "three eggs over easy." Well I'm sitting here looking at completely set yolks. So, I am being told I'm wrong and they are right. He's arguing with me and telling me they don't do refunds or exchanges. So I just wasted my money because this food was inedible. I guess this place has no integrity. They don't want to fix their mistakes. I don't appreciate being argued with and told I'm a liar, so I won't be returning. They obviously don't care enough about their customers anyway.