Reviews for Good Fellas Pizzeria

02/19/2025 - Kim M.
The garlic knots are incredible, the pizza is the best I've had in New Mexico, the gluten-free crust is delicious, the portions are massive, and despite the simple decor and long wait times, the friendly service and outstanding food make this local gem in Los Lunas a must-visit for pizza lovers.

06/12/2024 - Anson Q.
Good Eats

10/17/2022 - Darlene
Our favorite pizza place hands down! We absolutely love the pizza crust, so delicious!

02/19/2022 - Michelle
I have to warn you!
This place is addictive. The family is beautiful, the food is delicious and I cannot resist their Greek Salad and cheesy bread (even though I don't eat bread) at least once/week!
Their food is so good and staff so darling we have become regulars. Definitely must check them out!! Remember, it's a small family, locally owned business. ♡♡

01/10/2021 - veto
The best pizza I have had ever since I left Brooklyn

09/17/2020 - MenuPix User
Bad dishonest people! Don't order from them

09/25/2018 - MenuPix User
Today 9/25/18, I ordered a Cuban Sandwich from Goodfellas menu. It listed the sandwich as having roast pork and ham. The sandwich I got had ham, turkey but no roast pork,( which makes the sandwich unique).
I called to them to let them know and all they said was for the last three years they haven't put roast pork. on their sandwich, which is kind of weird because I ordered one before and it had roast pork My complaint is why still list the sandwich as a Cuban. List it for what it really is a BORING Ham and Turkey sandwich.

09/24/2017 - Margo
Best pizza this side of the Rio Grande great service great party atmosphere the kids really enjoyed the arcade and one lots of prizes thank you Goodfellas for a great birthday party your baklava is delicious

01/23/2016 - Sandy
Yummy Pizza and Garlic knots are soooo good! Other Items on Menu are good too. I would recommend trying it!

10/11/2015 - Rudy
Love the Wise Guys pizza and garlic knots! Salads are awesome too.