Reviews for McBride's Pizza Shop

01/07/2025 - Jada B.
The pizza and strombolis at this local spot in northern Butler County are absolutely fantastic, with a unique twist that sets them apart. Despite some ordering challenges, the delicious food and affordable prices make it a must-try in the area.

07/13/2024 - Selene A.
Good food and great service

02/09/2024 - MenuPix User
They mess up orders and don't have them when they are supposed to be

12/30/2023 - M.D.
Love your pizza have been buying it for years, but the last couple of times the crust in the middle has been doughy. Just an FYI

02/06/2021 - Lisa wilhelm
They are very polite, the best pizza in town.and they deliver when they say they will

07/17/2016 - Joan
Every time we want to order, can never get an answer. No one anwsers the phone. This has happed sevetal different times. We will not try again. We will go to Butler. Guess they do not need the business

02/02/2014 - Teresa
Love the garlic and butter wings. Pizza is great. We have ordered over 100 times since they opened. Always courteous staff, great delivery drivers. Once they forgot a sandwich on our delivery order and Jason the owner delivered it personally.

12/18/2013 - Mandy Mohan
Delicious!!!

07/01/2013 - Layne
I absolutely love Mcbrides. I have been eating pizza from Mcbrides for years and have never had an issue or a time I didn't like it. I'm so surprised by the bad reviews.

03/26/2011 - Wayne
Have ordered wings and pizza more than 50 times since shop opened and never had a problem! Glad they deliver to our cabin. Wish we had a shop this good in Pittsburgh!

03/22/2011 - Cynthia
Greasy garbage from greasy owners.

03/19/2011 - Heather
What a dive. I might have been able to stomach the food if the owners hadn't been so terrible. I'll never eat again. One of my girlfriends even told me not to go there. I should have listened.

03/19/2011 - Steve
Gag and Double Gag! That's just for the food. The service was even worse. Took forever to get the order, and I called ahead. Then they told me to go home and cook it because it might not be all the way done. WTF?

03/18/2011 - Sick to my Stomach
The absolute worst food I have ever eaten. It was so bad, I couldn't finish more than a few bites. Literally threw up. I also found a long hair in my sub sandwich. When I called to complain, they told me it was my problem and I couldn’t prove the hair was theirs. I will never eat there again, and I suggest no one else does either.