Reviews for Olde Theater Diner

03/16/2023 - Bob
Have always enjoyed the food, where eating or taking out.

04/12/2020 - Annmarie. Izzi
Great food. Like home made mamas cooking

08/14/2018 - MenuPix User
the cooks look filthy there're touching there hair there nose, and wiping there sweat off there face. nobody uses gloves. food was not good no more visits

06/05/2018 - Kathy
We eat at OTD weekly. Breakfast is very good, with multiple choices and fair prices. Servers are always excellent. Dinner is typically good too, with a wide variety of food choices from Grinders, Club sandwiches and Burgers to full dinners. The Prime Rib is always good here. But my favorite is the Chicken Pot Pie!
Their Pizza is great!!!!

05/04/2015 - Bruce
What a joke at your cruise night, the DJ should be fired , terrible the worst myself & wife have ever heard, not to mention how rude he was, saying to my wife if you don't like the show, then go home....that was exactly what we did, never again will we step back in you place, 5 of other friends with their classic cars left with us....sorry maybe we will try again on a different night ...absolutely the worst cruise night we have ever gone to.....

04/25/2015 - Horrendous
We've eaten at the Olde Theater Diner several times over the past 2 years with my parents & though it’s certainly not the cleanest place, the food has been fine, until last month when it was absolutely horrendous! So bad in fact, we'll never return. Not only was the place extremely filthy but our waitress convinced 2 of us to order specials – a meatloaf dinner & a turkey dinner both compete with soup, drink + dessert. The soup was very salty, though edible but both “specials” were so disgusting they should have been embarrassed to serve them.

My husband was served a massive slab of meatloaf that could feed all 4 of us & she coyly commented “you’re a big guy, so I made sure to give you extra”. It was covered in dark gravy (obviously trying to mask its consistency) where he was unable to slice it with a fork. It took a steak knife to slice into it & had the consistency of shoe leather. He actually stabbed it & it fell back onto his plate rattling the entire table (which was being held steady with a wad of filthy soggy napkins shoved under 1 leg). My turkey & stuffing dinner also arrived at the table with so much gravy it was dripping from the plate onto floor as she served it. The entire consistency looked exactly like vomit! I’ve seen dog food served that looked more appealing. I was famished & actually had to close my eyes to take a bite – it was inedible. It was as if the person it was previously served to was unable to eat it & they had opened a salt shaker & poured the entire contents onto the meal so it wouldn’t be served again. If smoking was still allowed in restaurants I would have expected to find a cigarette butt in it. Both meals were 100% inedible!

We tried to get our waitresses attention to no avail & by the time she returned my parents had finished eating their grinders (a much wiser choice) & instead of asking us if there was a problem had the audacity to ask us if we wanted to take our meals home!! My husband again stabbed the gravy covered shoe that was sitting in his plate & allowed it to fall onto the table, this time rattling the wobbly table so much 2 glasses fell onto the floor → to which she said “what’s wrong, you didn’t like it”?!! Never once did she offer to take the untouched meals off our bill & instead said she’d give us extra desert to take home. Our choices were Chocolate Cake, Key Lime Pie, & Cheesecake to which she added the Chocolate Cake & Key Lime Pie had been sitting in the display case nearly 2 weeks & she wouldn’t recommend them!! Along with our bill she gave us nearly a full Cheesecake to take home. Later that night still famished I went to cut into it & I had never seen a cheesecake of that consistency. No wonder → the bottom was covered in MOLD!!

The Olde Theater Diner lost 4 customers that night & I will continue to tell anyone that asks how deplorable it was. It was beyond disgusting & unless they clean up their act ASAP I see them going out of business SOON. I wouldn’t be surprised if people have encountered food poisoning from this filthy establishment. Stay away or be warned. Unfortunately I'm unable to give them a negative rating.

03/23/2015 - Craig
Everything at this place is good. From the buffalo chicken wrap, pizza, appetizers, etc.. the decor leaves a bit to be desired but who cares when the food is good. I love their club sandwiches, and pizza's. Give it a try you won't be disappointed. Way better than Wescott House in my opinion.