Reviews for Stachey's Olde Time Pizzeria

04/14/2025 - Dorothy L.
The Italian-style pizza is delicious, and the variety of salads is impressive, with the Caesar salad topped with Buffalo chicken fingers being a personal favorite. The steak and cheese sub stands out as one of the best I've had in years, and while the chicken Alfredo was average, the generous portions make it a satisfying choice overall.

12/17/2024 - Rochelle N.
The Italian-style pizza is absolutely mouthwatering, and their salad selection is surprisingly extensive. I was pleasantly surprised by the delicious subs they offer as well. The convenience of grabbing a quick bite here is unbeatable - it's easily accessible and service is swift.

07/08/2024 - Bobbie Y.
Good service and good food

03/01/2018 - Rick D. Lucas
We had the $5 everyday lunch special (meatball parm) and is was ready in minutes. The bread was very, very fresh, the sauce was perfect and the (3) meatballs were outrageous. You we allowed any 20 oz. drink included.

Service was friendly and attentive.

Overall a very positive experience.

We will certainly be back for legit Italian cuisine!

07/13/2017 - Bob hillard
Seriously you ran out of steak tips!

11/09/2012 - Edwin
We only have 30 minutes for lunch break, we ordered a large House deluxe pizza. It was in 25 minutes but it was the wrong order. We called in and the person answering the phone said that it would be another 30 minutes before we got the right order. Not very competent.

07/29/2010 - Patty
What happened to customer service at this restaurant?? Two employees were rude when an item was incorrectly prepared and returned to be properly remade. The unprofessional remarks that were made by the staff as I tried to rectify the situation with my order. The immature employees should have been properly trained, before waiting on customers on how to handle mistakes due to lack of communication between the front counter staff and the preparers of the food.

I will not be returning to this establishment in the future due to this experience. If the situation was handled professional, the order remade properly, it would have left a much different impression of this restaurant and I would be recommend it to friends, but it if is mentioned in conversation I will be telling them of the bad experience.

05/24/2010 - Ken H
I had a pepperoni pizza from Stacheys last Friday and I have to say it was the best pizza I've had in a long time. Will be back again.